Skip to content

Collars: payoff, zero-cost collars and the capped range

By Investor Wisdom Daily Team·

Leo, a hypothetical investor, owns 100 shares of a fictional company, Birchwood Inc, at $50. He has read the protective puts lesson and likes the idea of a floor at $45, but not the cost: $0.60 a share every quarter adds up to 4.8% of the position a year. Then he notices that a $55 call on the same shares sells for $0.95. If he sells that call, the put is paid for and he even has $0.35 left over. What has he given up?

He has given up the upside above $55. That exchange, a floor paid for by a ceiling, is a collar. This lesson works through it in numbers, using the same hypothetical three-month option chain as the protective puts lesson. It assumes you know Calls and puts and Covered calls. This lesson describes how the strategy works and does not recommend it or any security.

A collar means owning shares, buying a put below the current price and selling (writing) a call above it, usually one contract of each per 100 shares, with the same expiration. The put sets a floor; the call sets a ceiling; the call’s premium pays for some or all of the put’s. Between the two strikes the position moves with the shares. The Options Industry Council (OIC) describes it as a “slightly less-than-complete hedge against the effects of a possible near-term decline” (OIC, collar, accessed 2026-11-19): slightly less than complete because losses down to the put strike are still taken.

For 100 shares bought at price P, a put bought at strike Kp for premium p and a call sold at strike Kc for premium c, held to expiration, let the net premium be c − p (a credit if positive, a debit if negative):

  • Maximum loss = (P − Kp − (c − p)) × 100. It applies at any stock price at or below the put strike.
  • Maximum profit = (Kc − P + (c − p)) × 100. It applies at any stock price at or above the call strike.
  • Breakeven at expiration = P − (c − p): below the purchase price for a net credit, above it for a net debit.

Leo’s numbers: 100 shares at $50, a $45 put bought for $0.60 and a $55 call sold for $0.95. Net premium: $0.95 − $0.60 = $0.35 a share, a $35 credit.

  • Maximum loss: ($50 − $45 − $0.35) × 100 = $465.
  • Maximum profit: ($55 − $50 + $0.35) × 100 = $535.
  • Breakeven: $50 − $0.35 = $49.65.

Profit or loss at expiration, by stock price:

Stock at expiration Shares P/L Long put P/L Short call P/L Collar total Shares alone
$0 −$5,000 +$4,440 +$95 −$465 −$5,000
$40 −$1,000 +$440 +$95 −$465 −$1,000
$45 −$500 −$60 +$95 −$465 −$500
$49.65 −$35 −$60 +$95 $0 −$35
$50 $0 −$60 +$95 +$35 $0
$55 +$500 −$60 +$95 +$535 +$500
$60 +$1,000 −$60 −$405 +$535 +$1,000
$70 +$2,000 −$60 −$1,405 +$535 +$2,000

What the table shows:

  • The result lives in a band from −$465 to +$535, whatever the shares do before expiry.
  • Between $45 and $55, the collar tracks the shares plus the $35 credit.
  • Above $55, the call takes every extra dollar. At $70 the shares alone made $2,000, so the collar gave up $2,000 − $535 = $1,465 of gain to the call buyer.

A collar is literally the two strategies stacked on the same shares. Using the same prices:

Position Max loss Max profit Breakeven
Covered call ($55 call at $0.95) $4,905 $595 $49.05
Protective put ($45 put at $0.60) $560 unlimited $50.60
Collar (both) $465 $535 $49.65

The covered call alone has a capped gain but nearly the full downside; the protective put alone has a floor but pays for it. The collar takes the cap from one and the floor from the other.

A zero-cost collar chooses the call strike so that the call’s premium equals the put’s. In this chain the $57 call also sells for $0.60, so buying the $45 put and selling the $57 call nets $0.60 − $0.60 = $0.

  • Maximum loss: ($50 − $45) × 100 = $500.
  • Maximum profit: ($57 − $50) × 100 = $700.
  • Breakeven: $50, the purchase price.

“Zero-cost” refers only to the premiums. Commissions and bid-ask spreads still apply, and the real cost is the gain above $57 that the call buyer would collect. Whether the ceiling can sit further above the price than the floor sits below it depends on the chain; when the market prices puts expensively relative to calls, a zero-cost collar may need a lower ceiling.

Example 3: what changes with a tight collar

Section titled “Example 3: what changes with a tight collar”

Now suppose Leo buys the $50 put for $2.25 and sells a $52 call for $1.85: a net debit of $2.25 − $1.85 = $0.40.

  • Maximum loss: ($50 − $50 + $0.40) × 100 = $40.
  • Maximum profit: ($52 − $50 − $0.40) × 100 = $160.
  • Breakeven: $50 + $0.40 = $50.40.

The band is now −$40 to +$160 for three months. The tighter the collar, the less the position behaves like a stock at all. Moving both strikes toward the stock price removes most of the risk and most of the return together.

The chain in these lessons is built to be internally consistent. At the same strike and expiry, put-call parity says the call minus the put is, in theory, roughly the interest on the strike price for the period, less dividends due before expiry. Here the $50 call is $2.75 and the $50 put is $2.25, a $0.50 gap, which matches $50 × 4% × 0.25 = $0.50 at a hypothetical 4% a year for three months, with no dividend. That is also why the calls in this chain are worth a little more than puts the same distance from the price, and why a $45 put pays for a call further out than $55. Real quotes add spreads and skew, so the match is only approximate.

US-listed stock options are usually American style, so the call can be exercised, and Leo assigned, on any business day before expiration. OIC notes that early assignment of the short call is possible at any time but generally happens just before a stock goes ex-dividend. A call holder gives up its remaining time value by exercising (Intrinsic and extrinsic value explains why), so exercise makes sense to the holder mainly when a dividend is worth more than that time value.

Illustration. Birchwood is at $62 and the $55 call trades at $7.20, so its time value is $7.20 − $7 = $0.20 a share. A $0.50 dividend is due. Leo is assigned and delivers the shares at $55. His result is the collar’s maximum: ($55 − $50) × 100 + $35 = $535, but without the $50 dividend he may have expected. Because Leo owned the shares, he could deliver them, so the assignment only ends the position early; it adds no new loss. One thing remains: the $45 put. It is now a standalone long put with no shares behind it, worth little with the stock at $62, and it needs a decision of its own: sell it, or let it run as a separate bet.

Collars can affect how gains, losses and holding periods on the shares are treated, and the rules can be complex. In the US, IRS Publication 550 (accessed 2026-11-19) covers options and related positions. Rules differ by country and account type, so check the rules that apply to you or ask a qualified tax professional.

Open the option payoff calculator and enter three legs to reproduce Example 1:

  • Leg 1: Position “Long (bought)”, Instrument “Stock”, Entry price per share 50, Quantity 100 shares.
  • Leg 2: Position “Long (bought)”, Instrument “Put option”, Strike 45, Premium 0.60, Quantity 1 contract.
  • Leg 3: Position “Short (sold or written)”, Instrument “Call option”, Strike 55, Premium 0.95, Quantity 1 contract.

Confirm the maximum profit of $535, the maximum loss of $465 and the breakeven of $49.65. Then change leg 3 to strike 57 and premium 0.60 for the zero-cost collar of Example 2, and watch the breakeven move to $50. Notice that the line is flat on both sides.

  • Thinking “zero-cost” means free. The premiums cancel, but the gain above the call strike is given away, and spreads and commissions still apply.
  • Expecting full protection. The floor is at the put strike, not at the purchase price. In Example 1 a fall to $45 still loses $465.
  • Forgetting the dividend and the early assignment. Shares can be called away before expiry, usually just before an ex-dividend date, and the dividend goes with them.
  • Leaving a lone leg behind. If the call is assigned or the shares are sold, the put remains; if the put is sold early, the shares carry a short call without a floor.
  • Assuming the band lasts. Both options expire on the same day. After that the shares are unprotected and uncapped until a new collar is built at new prices.

Brokers usually let you enter a collar as a single order with a net limit price, which reduces the risk of filling one leg and not the other. Writing the call requires options approval, and an assignment notice arrives if the shares are called away. FINRA’s options page (accessed 2026-11-19) describes option risks and the obligations of writers. OIC’s collar page sets out the strategy’s limited gain and loss and its assignment risk.

  1. You own 100 shares at $40, buy a $36 put for $0.80 and sell a $45 call for $0.50. What are the maximum loss, maximum profit and breakeven?
Answer to question 1

The net premium is $0.50 − $0.80 = −$0.30, a debit. Maximum loss: ($40 − $36 + $0.30) × 100 = $430. Maximum profit: ($45 − $40 − $0.30) × 100 = $470. Breakeven: $40 + $0.30 = $40.30.

  1. In Example 1 the stock ends at $70. Why is the result $535?
Answer to question 2

The shares are effectively sold at $55: $500 of gain, plus the $35 net credit. The other $1,465 of the move goes to the call buyer.

  1. What does “zero-cost” refer to in a zero-cost collar?
Answer to question 3

Only the premiums: the call sold brings in as much as the put costs. The position still gives away upside above the call strike and still pays trading costs.

  1. After early assignment of the short call, what is left?
Answer to question 4

The long put, with no shares to protect. It has to be managed on its own.

  • A collar is owned shares plus a bought put plus a sold call: a floor and a ceiling on the same expiry.
  • Max loss = (purchase price − put strike − net credit) × 100; max profit = (call strike − purchase price + net credit) × 100; breakeven = purchase price − net credit.
  • A zero-cost collar balances the premiums, but the upside above the call strike is still given away.
  • The short call can be assigned early, most often before an ex-dividend date, leaving the put on its own.

Compare the floor on its own in Protective puts, the ceiling on its own in Covered calls, and how the position’s sensitivity to the stock changes in Delta.

For educational purposes only. This material does not provide investment advice.