Skip to content

Cash-on-cash return and DSCR

By Investor Wisdom Daily Team·

Sam, a hypothetical investor, is looking at a small rental house. One option is to pay the whole price in cash. The other is to put 25% down and borrow the rest. The loan means far less cash goes in, so it is tempting to assume the return on that cash must be higher. Sometimes it is. Sometimes the loan payment eats so much of the rent that the return on cash falls, and a bad year turns into a loss.

This lesson defines net operating income, cap rate, debt service, cash-on-cash return and the debt service coverage ratio (DSCR), then works through one property bought with cash and with a loan at two rates, and a stress case. All people, properties, rents, loans and rates here are hypothetical.

Net operating income (NOI) is a property’s yearly gross income minus its operating expenses. The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) handbook on commercial real estate lending counts rent plus other property income, such as parking or laundry, as gross income. Operating expenses are the costs of running and normally maintaining the property, including a reserve for replacements; they do not include interest or principal (OCC Comptroller’s Handbook, Commercial Real Estate Lending, as of November 2026). So NOI is measured before the mortgage. What the owner keeps after the loan is paid is cash flow after debt service, and comparing it with the cash put in gives the cash-on-cash return. The DSCR asks the lender’s question: how many times over does NOI cover the loan payments?

  • NOI = gross income − operating expenses (vacancy, property taxes, insurance, repairs, management and reserves; not loan payments).
  • Cap rate = NOI ÷ price. The OCC handbook defines the capitalization rate as the ratio of stabilized NOI to sale price. It is a property yield with no financing in it.
  • Annual debt service = 12 × monthly principal and interest payment. The payment comes from the amortization formula.
  • Cash flow after debt service = NOI − annual debt service.
  • Cash-on-cash return = cash flow after debt service ÷ total cash invested, where cash invested is the down payment plus closing costs and any upfront repairs. This is plain arithmetic for one year; there is no single official definition.
  • DSCR = NOI ÷ annual debt service. The OCC handbook uses this definition and calls it a measure of the borrower’s ability to service the debt.

Two more ratios explain whether a loan helps or hurts:

  • Property yield = NOI ÷ total cost (price plus closing costs and repairs). This is the cash-on-cash return if no money is borrowed.
  • Loan constant = annual debt service ÷ loan amount. This is what the loan costs each year, interest and principal together, per dollar borrowed.

If the property yield is above the loan constant, each borrowed dollar earns more than it costs, and borrowing raises cash-on-cash return (positive leverage). If it is below, borrowing lowers cash-on-cash return (negative leverage).

A hypothetical house costs $300,000, with $10,000 of closing costs and repairs, so the total cost is $310,000. Rent is $30,000 a year, and operating expenses including vacancy and reserves are $12,000.

  • NOI: $30,000 − $12,000 = $18,000.
  • Cap rate: $18,000 ÷ $300,000 = 6.0%.
  • Cash-on-cash, all cash: $18,000 ÷ $310,000 ≈ 5.8%. This is also the property yield. With no loan there is no debt service, so DSCR does not apply.

Example 2: the same property with a loan at two rates

Section titled “Example 2: the same property with a loan at two rates”

Now Sam puts 25% down: $75,000, so the loan is $225,000 for 30 years. Cash invested is $75,000 + $10,000 = $85,000. NOI is still $18,000, because NOI does not depend on the loan.

Item Loan at 5% Loan at 3.5%
Monthly principal + interest $1,207.85 $1,010.35
Annual debt service $14,494.20 $12,124.20
Loan constant 6.44% 5.39%
Cash flow after debt service $3,505.80 $5,875.80
Cash-on-cash return $3,505.80 ÷ $85,000 ≈ 4.1% $5,875.80 ÷ $85,000 ≈ 6.9%
DSCR $18,000 ÷ $14,494.20 ≈ 1.24 $18,000 ÷ $12,124.20 ≈ 1.48
  • At 5%: the loan constant (6.44%) is above the property yield (5.8%). Borrowing lowers cash-on-cash from 5.8% to 4.1%. Sam puts in less cash, earns a smaller percentage return on it, and also carries a loan.
  • At 3.5%: the loan constant (5.39%) is below the property yield (5.8%). Borrowing raises cash-on-cash from 5.8% to 6.9%.

The property is the same in both columns. Only the cost of the debt changed, and it decided whether leverage helped.

Keep the 5% loan, and suppose a long vacancy and a large repair cut NOI by 25%, from $18,000 to $13,500. The loan payment does not change.

  • Cash flow: $13,500 − $14,494.20 = −$994.20. Sam has to add money to keep the loan current.
  • Cash-on-cash: −$994.20 ÷ $85,000 ≈ −1.2%.
  • DSCR: $13,500 ÷ $14,494.20 ≈ 0.93, below 1.0: NOI no longer covers the payments.

Bought with cash, the same bad year would still return $13,500 ÷ $310,000 ≈ 4.4%. The loan turned a weaker year into a loss. Leverage magnifies changes in NOI in both directions, because the debt service stays fixed while the income moves.

  • One year only. Cash-on-cash looks at a single year’s cash flow. It ignores rent growth, changes in expenses and when cash arrives.
  • Principal paydown. Part of each payment reduces the loan balance, which builds equity. The cash-on-cash formula here leaves it out, so a loan with fast paydown can look worse than it is.
  • Changes in value. Appreciation or a fall in price does not appear in cash-on-cash or DSCR. The OCC handbook notes that rising interest rates may push cap rates up and property values down even if the property itself is unchanged.
  • What counts as cash invested. Leaving out closing costs, repairs or reserves makes the return look higher than it is.
  • Different “DSCR” definitions. Lenders do not all calculate DSCR the same way, so before comparing a quoted DSCR with the formula here, check what income and which payments it uses.

Open the rental property calculator. Its default inputs are a $220,000 price, rent of $2,050 a month, 25% down, closing costs of 2% of the price, a 7% rate for 30 years, property taxes of $3,600 a year, insurance of $1,500 a year, no HOA dues, $50 a month of other costs, 5% vacancy, 5% maintenance and 8% management. Note that the tool counts the closing costs (2% of the price, $4,400 here) in cash invested.

  • Defaults: payment $1,098 a month, NOI $14,632, cash invested $59,400, cash flow $122 a month, cap rate 6.65%, cash-on-cash 2.46%, DSCR 1.11.
  • Change the down payment to 20%: payment $1,171 a month, cash invested $48,400, cash flow $48 a month, cash-on-cash 1.20%, DSCR 1.04. Less cash went in, yet the return on it fell: at 7% this loan’s cost is above the property’s yield.
  • Change the down payment to 100%: no payment, cash invested $224,400, cash flow $1,219 a month, cash-on-cash 6.52%, and DSCR shows “n/a (no loan)”.
  • Back at 25% down, the downside case (rent 10% lower, expenses 10% higher): NOI $11,755, cash flow −$118 a month, cap rate 5.34%, cash-on-cash −2.39%, DSCR 0.89.

The mortgage calculator shows the payment for any loan amount and rate on its own.

  • Treating NOI as take-home income. NOI comes before the mortgage. Cash flow is NOI minus debt service.
  • Assuming leverage always raises returns. It does only when the property yield is above the loan constant.
  • Reading a higher cash-on-cash as a safer deal. More borrowing can raise cash-on-cash while pushing DSCR toward 1.0, leaving little room for a bad year.
  • Counting only the down payment as cash invested. Closing costs, repairs and reserves are cash too.
  • Treating a DSCR of 1.0 as enough. At exactly 1.0, any vacancy or repair makes the year negative.
  • Treating the cap rate as the investor’s return. The cap rate ignores financing entirely.

Lenders set their own minimum DSCR for rental and commercial loans, and the figure varies by lender and property. The OCC handbook does not give one number: it says the appropriate DSCR depends on the amortization period and how volatile the cash flow is, so a lower ratio may be acceptable with a shorter amortization period or very stable income such as long-term leases to strong tenants, while volatile income, such as a hotel’s, may call for a higher one. It also says loans on properties with less volatile cash flow and value may merit higher loan-to-value ratios, while higher-risk properties should carry more equity (OCC Comptroller’s Handbook, as of November 2026).

For a single-family rental financed with a conventional mortgage, Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide nets rental income against the full monthly payment of principal, interest, taxes, insurance and association dues when qualifying a borrower; a loss is counted as a monthly obligation (Fannie Mae Selling Guide, General Rental Income Information, as of November 2026). That is a qualifying test for the borrower, not a DSCR.

  1. A property has NOI of $20,000 and annual debt service of $16,000. What is its DSCR?
Show the answer to question 1

1.25. $20,000 ÷ $16,000.

  1. The owner put in $80,000 of cash in total. What is the cash-on-cash return?
Show the answer to question 2

5%. Cash flow is $20,000 − $16,000 = $4,000, and $4,000 ÷ $80,000 = 5%.

  1. A property yields 6% on its total cost and the loan constant is 7%. Does borrowing raise or lower cash-on-cash return?
Show the answer to question 3

It lowers it. Each borrowed dollar costs 7% a year in payments but earns only 6%, so the shortfall comes out of the owner’s cash flow.

  1. Why does a fall in rent hurt a borrowed purchase more than a cash purchase, in percentage terms?
Show the answer to question 4

The loan payment does not fall when rent falls. So every dollar of lost NOI comes straight out of the smaller cash flow left after debt service, and that loss is divided by a smaller amount of cash invested, which makes the percentage drop bigger.

  • NOI is income minus operating expenses, before any loan payments; cash flow after debt service is what is left for the owner.
  • Cash-on-cash return = cash flow after debt service ÷ total cash invested, including closing costs and repairs.
  • DSCR = NOI ÷ annual debt service; below 1.0, the property does not cover its loan.
  • Leverage raises cash-on-cash only when the property yield is above the loan constant. In the examples, the same house returned 4.1% with a 5% loan and 6.9% with a 3.5% loan, against 5.8% for cash.
  • Leverage magnifies bad years too: a 25% fall in NOI took the 5% loan case to a DSCR of 0.93 and a negative return.

For educational purposes only. This material does not provide investment advice.