Case study: a first options position, step by step
By Investor Wisdom Daily Team·
Riley, a hypothetical investor who has owned index funds for a few years, has read the options lessons and wants to see one contract from start to finish on paper. The stock is fictional: call it Example Co, trading at $40. Riley pictures paying $1.25 a share for one call with a $42 strike that expires in 60 days, and asks: what exactly does that buy, what can happen by expiry, and what might the position be worth halfway there?
This case study walks through those questions using the published options lessons and two calculators. It is strictly descriptive. Riley, Example Co and every price are fictional; nothing here says whether anyone should open, hold or close an options position. Options can lose their whole value, and the box above describes the main risks.
The position (hypothetical)
Section titled “The position (hypothetical)”| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Stock price today | $40 |
| Contract | 1 call, strike $42, 60 days to expiry |
| Premium paid | $1.25 per share |
| Multiplier | 100 shares per contract |
| Cost | $1.25 × 100 = $125 |
| Breakeven at expiry | $42 + $1.25 = $43.25 |
| Most the buyer can lose | $125 (the premium) |
For comparison, 100 shares of the stock would cost $40 × 100 = $4,000. Calls and puts: rights, obligations and payoffs explains the right a call buyer holds, the multiplier and why the buyer’s loss is limited to the premium, while the seller of the same call takes on an obligation with much larger possible losses.
To see whether $1.25 is in line with a pricing model, Riley enters the stock price, strike, 60 days, a 30% implied volatility, a 4% rate and no dividend in the Black-Scholes calculator. It gives a model call value of about $1.24 (more exactly $1.2372), so the hypothetical $1.25 is about $0.0128 above the model. A model value is not a quote; real prices come from the market, with a bid below and an ask above.
Walk-through 1: what the $1.25 is made of
Section titled “Walk-through 1: what the $1.25 is made of”Intrinsic and extrinsic value of an option splits a premium into two parts. With the stock at $40 and the strike at $42, the call is $42 − $40 = $2 out of the money, so its intrinsic value is $0 and all $1.25 is extrinsic (time) value. That has two consequences the lesson describes:
- If nothing changes, that time value shrinks as expiry approaches, and at expiry an out-of-the-money call is worth nothing.
- For the position to break even at expiry, the stock has to rise from $40 to $43.25, a move of $43.25 − $40 = $3.25, or 3.25 ÷ 40 = 8.125%, within 60 days.
Walk-through 2: outcomes at expiry
Section titled “Walk-through 2: outcomes at expiry”At expiry only intrinsic value is left. Per contract, the profit or loss is (stock price − strike − premium) × 100 when the stock finishes above $42, and −$125 otherwise. The same moves with 100 shares bought at $40 are shown for comparison:
| Stock price at expiry | Call: intrinsic per share | Call: profit or loss | 100 shares: profit or loss |
|---|---|---|---|
| $36 | $0 | −$125 | (36 − 40) × 100 = −$400 |
| $40 | $0 | −$125 | $0 |
| $42 | $0 | −$125 | (42 − 40) × 100 = $200 |
| $43.25 | $1.25 | $0 | $325 |
| $45 | $3 | (45 − 42 − 1.25) × 100 = $175 | $500 |
| $48 | $6 | (48 − 42 − 1.25) × 100 = $475 | $800 |
The table shows the trade-off the lessons describe. The call’s loss stops at $125, while the shares can lose more in dollars. But the call loses its whole $125 in three of the six rows, including when the stock rises to $42, where the shares gain. In percentage terms the swings are larger: at $45 the call gains 175 ÷ 125 = 140% of its cost, while the shares gain 500 ÷ 4,000 = 12.5%. In the lower rows the call loses 100% of its cost.
The option payoff calculator draws this table as a line: enter a long call, strike 42, premium 1.25, one contract.
Walk-through 3: a halfway check with the model
Section titled “Walk-through 3: a halfway check with the model”Thirty days later, with 30 days left, the position has a value before expiry: intrinsic value plus whatever time value remains. The Black-Scholes calculator estimates it for a few hypothetical cases (same 4% rate, no dividend):
| Day-30 case | Stock | Implied volatility | Model value | Profit or loss vs $1.25 paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nothing moves | $40 | 30% | $0.6648 | (0.6648 − 1.25) × 100 = −$58.52 |
| Stock up $3 | $43 | 30% | $2.0945 | +$84.45 |
| Stock down $2 | $38 | 30% | $0.2237 | −$102.63 |
| Volatility falls 5 points | $40 | 25% | $0.4671 | −$78.29 |
| Stock up, volatility falls | $43 | 25% | $1.8658 | +$61.58 |
Each row lines up with a lesson:
- Time. With no price change, the model value falls from about $1.2372 to $0.6648, a drop of $0.5724 in 30 days. Theta: how time decay is measured explains why decay continues, and speeds up, as expiry nears.
- Price. At the start the calculator shows a delta of about 0.39, so a $1 move in the stock was estimated to move the contract by roughly 0.3873 × 100 ≈ $38.73. Delta: how an option’s price follows the stock explains why delta is an estimate that changes as the stock moves.
- Volatility. At $40, a five-point drop in implied volatility lowers the model value by $0.6648 − $0.4671 = $0.1977 a share. At $43 it turns an $84.45 gain into $61.58, a difference of $22.87. Vega and implied volatility describes this effect, including “IV crush”.
The model assumes European exercise, constant volatility and no fees. Real bids for the same contract could differ, and the gap between bid and ask is a cost too.
Try it with the calculators
Section titled “Try it with the calculators”- Black-Scholes calculator: stock 40, strike 42, 60 days, volatility 30, rate 4, dividend 0. The call should be about $1.237. Change days to 30 to see the “nothing moves” row, then the stock to 43 or 38 and the volatility to 25.
- Option payoff calculator: one long call, strike 42, premium 1.25. Check the breakeven of $43.25 and the maximum loss of $125. Add a second leg of 100 shares at 40 to compare the two lines.
Questions to think about
Section titled “Questions to think about”These questions are for describing the position, not for deciding whether to take one.
- How much of the $1.25 premium is time value, and what has to happen for any of it to become intrinsic value?
- In which rows of the expiry table do the call and the shares move in opposite directions?
- How would the breakeven and maximum loss change with a $40 strike at a higher premium?
- Why can a stock rise and the call still lose value before expiry, as in the last row of the halfway table?
- How does the seller’s side of this same contract look in each row of the expiry table?
Worksheet
Section titled “Worksheet”Print this worksheet: use your browser's print command (Ctrl+P on Windows and Linux, Command+P on a Mac). The printout leaves out the site's menus so the blank tables fit on paper. You can also download the blank worksheet as a CSV file for a spreadsheet.
| Line | Value |
|---|---|
| Stock price today | |
| Call or put | |
| Strike | |
| Days to expiry | |
| Premium per share | |
| Number of contracts | |
| Cost (premium × 100 × contracts) | |
| Breakeven at expiry (call: strike + premium) | |
| Intrinsic value today | |
| Time value today (premium − intrinsic) | |
| Most the buyer can lose |
| Stock price at expiry | Intrinsic value per share | Option profit or loss | Same move with 100 shares |
|---|---|---|---|
| Case | Stock price | Implied volatility | Days left | Model value | Profit or loss vs premium paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lessons and tools used in this case
Section titled “Lessons and tools used in this case”- Calls and puts: rights, obligations and payoffs
- Intrinsic and extrinsic value of an option
- Delta: how an option’s price follows the stock
- Theta: how time decay is measured
- Vega and implied volatility
- Calculators: Black-Scholes and option payoff
For educational purposes only. This material does not provide investment advice.