Skip to content

Case study: paying down three debts

By Investor Wisdom Daily Team·

Dana and Chris, a hypothetical couple in their thirties, sit down with three statements: a credit card, a store card and a car loan. They can put $650 a month toward debt and want to see what that buys: which debt to aim extra money at, how long it takes, and what a loan offer in the mail would change. This case study works through those questions with the published lessons and the debt payoff and loan calculators. It applies the methods; the lessons linked at each step explain them.

Dana, Chris and every balance, rate and offer below are fictional. The case describes outcomes under stated assumptions and does not recommend a method, lender or product.

Debt Balance APR Minimum or fixed payment Credit limit
Credit card $3,800 25.99% $95 $6,000
Store card $900 19.99% $30 $1,500
Car loan $9,600 6.9% $310 (fixed) n/a
Total $14,300 $435 $7,500

The balances add to $3,800 + $900 + $9,600 = $14,300 and the payments to $95 + $30 + $310 = $435. With a $650 budget, $650 − $435 = $215 a month is extra. The same conventions as the debt avalanche vs debt snowball lesson apply: interest is the balance × APR ÷ 12, added each month before payments; minimums stay fixed; there is no new borrowing; and a paid-off debt’s minimum rolls to the next target.

Walk-through 1: what the statements already show

Section titled “Walk-through 1: what the statements already show”

Utilization. Credit utilization is the balance divided by the limit. The card is at 3,800 ÷ 6,000 ≈ 63.33%, the store card at 900 ÷ 1,500 = 60%, and overall (3,800 + 900) ÷ 7,500 ≈ 62.67%. The lesson explains how this ratio is reported and why it moves as balances fall. The car loan is an instalment loan, so it has no limit and no utilization.

Interest in month 1. Card: $3,800 × 0.2599 ÷ 12 ≈ $82.30. Store card: $900 × 0.1999 ÷ 12 ≈ $14.99. Car loan: $9,600 × 0.069 ÷ 12 = $55.20. That is $82.30 + $14.99 + $55.20 = $152.49 of the first $650 going to interest.

The car loan’s schedule. How amortization works shows why the first car payment is $55.20 of interest and $310 − $55.20 = $254.80 of principal. Paid on its own at $310 a month, the remaining balance clears in 35 months with about $1,002.50 of interest.

Walk-through 2: avalanche and snowball at $650 a month

Section titled “Walk-through 2: avalanche and snowball at $650 a month”

The two orders differ only in which debt gets the extra $215:

Method Target order
Avalanche Credit card (25.99%) → store card (19.99%) → car loan (6.9%)
Snowball Store card ($900) → credit card ($3,800) → car loan ($9,600)

Running the month-by-month rules until every balance is zero (the debt payoff calculator does this):

Result Avalanche Snowball
First debt paid off Month 15 (credit card) Month 4 (store card)
Second debt paid off Month 17 (store card) Month 17 (credit card)
Last debt paid off Month 25 (car loan) Month 25 (car loan)
Final payment $426.58 $489.69
Total paid 24 × $650 + $426.58 = $16,026.58 24 × $650 + $489.69 = $16,089.69
Total interest $16,026.58 − $14,300 = $1,726.58 $16,089.69 − $14,300 = $1,789.69

Interest by debt: avalanche $664.80 (card) + $206.48 (store card) + $855.30 (car) = $1,726.58; snowball $894.84 + $36.72 + $858.13 = $1,789.69.

The gap is $1,789.69 − $1,726.58 = $63.11, much smaller than the $624.25 in the lesson’s example. Two features of this household explain it: the snowball’s first target is small ($900), so it is cleared in 4 months, and the two card rates are only 6 points apart. Both orders also leave the car loan, the cheapest debt, for last. The snowball closes its first account 17 − 4 = 13 months earlier than the avalanche; the lesson describes the behavioural argument that some people weigh against the extra interest.

Walk-through 3: what a different budget changes

Section titled “Walk-through 3: what a different budget changes”
Monthly budget Method Months Total interest
$435 (minimums only) Avalanche 43 $4,315.66
$435 (minimums only) Snowball 43 $4,320.04
$650 Avalanche 25 $1,726.58
$650 Snowball 25 $1,789.69
$800 Avalanche 20 $1,284.16
$800 Snowball 20 $1,325.48

At minimums only, the order is worth $4,320.04 − $4,315.66 = $4.38. At $800 it is worth $1,325.48 − $1,284.16 = $41.32. Moving from $435 to $650 cuts interest by $4,315.66 − $1,726.58 = $2,589.08 (avalanche) and the timeline by 43 − 25 = 18 months. As in the lesson, the size of the monthly amount moves the result far more than the order.

Walk-through 4: reading a consolidation offer

Section titled “Walk-through 4: reading a consolidation offer”

A letter offers Dana and Chris a personal loan of $3,800 + $900 = $4,700 to pay off both cards: 12.99% APR, 36 months, no origination fee stated. Comparing loan offers by APR and total cost lists what to compare. With the payment formula from the amortization lesson:

  • Monthly payment: $4,700 × (0.1299 ÷ 12) ÷ (1 − 1 ÷ (1 + 0.1299 ÷ 12)^36) ≈ $158.34.
  • Interest if paid on schedule: 36 × $158.34 − $4,700 ≈ $1,000.24 (about $1,000.20 before the payment is rounded to cents).
  • The new payment is $158.34 − ($95 + $30) = $33.34 a month more than the two card minimums it would replace.

What the offer does not say matters as much. A 3% origination fee would cost $4,700 × 0.03 = $141 and raise the APR, as the loan offer lesson shows. A lower rate also only changes the outcome if the paid-off cards are not used again; the case does not assume either way. The loan calculator reproduces the payment and total interest for any amount, rate and term.

  • Debt payoff calculator: enter the card (3800 at 25.99, minimum 95), the store card (900 at 19.99, minimum 30) and the car loan (9600 at 6.9, minimum 310), with a budget of 650. It should show 25 months for both methods and about $1,727 of interest for the avalanche and $1,790 for the snowball (it rounds to whole dollars). Then try 435 and 800.
  • Enter only the car loan with a budget of 310 to see the 35-month schedule on its own.
  • Loan calculator: enter 4700, 12.99 and a term of 3 years to check the consolidation payment of about $158.34 and roughly $1,000 of interest. It does not include fees, so add any fee by hand.

These questions describe the situation from different angles; none has one right answer.

  • Which result in Walk-through 2 would matter more to this household, the $63.11 of interest or the account closed 13 months sooner, and why might two people weigh them differently?
  • How does the utilization in Walk-through 1 change month by month under each order?
  • What would happen to both timelines if one month’s $650 were not available?
  • Which details of the consolidation offer are missing from the letter, and where would they appear in the loan documents?
  • How would the order change if the store card had a 0% promotional rate ending in six months?

Print this worksheet: use your browser's print command (Ctrl+P on Windows and Linux, Command+P on a Mac). The printout leaves out the site's menus so the blank tables fit on paper. You can also download the blank worksheet as a CSV file for a spreadsheet.

Table 1: debts from the latest statements
DebtBalanceAPRMonthly rate (APR ÷ 12)Minimum or fixed paymentCredit limit (cards)
Total
Table 2: monthly budget for debt
LineAmount
Total monthly budget for debt
Sum of minimum and fixed payments
Extra (budget − minimums)
Overall card utilization (card balances ÷ card limits)
Table 3: payoff order under each method
StepAvalanche target (highest APR)Snowball target (smallest balance)
1
2
3
4
Table 4: results from the debt payoff calculator
MethodMonthly budgetMonthsTotal interestFirst debt paid off (month)
Avalanche
Snowball

For educational purposes only. This material does not provide investment advice.