Debt avalanche vs debt snowball
By Investor Wisdom Daily Team·
Three bills, one extra $200
Section titled “Three bills, one extra $200”Jordan, a hypothetical 31-year-old, has three debts and a budget of $500 a month for them. The minimum payments add up to $300, so there is $200 extra each month. Where should the extra go? One approach says: put it on the debt with the highest interest rate. Another says: put it on the smallest balance so it disappears quickly. Both approaches have names.
This lesson works both methods on the same hypothetical debts, month by month, and shows how many months each takes and how much interest each costs. It also explains the argument for each without deciding for you. All people, debts, rates and minimums are hypothetical.
The idea in one paragraph
Section titled “The idea in one paragraph”Both methods follow the same routine. Every month you pay the minimum payment (the smallest amount each lender accepts) on every debt, then put every remaining dollar of your budget on one target debt. When a debt is paid off, its minimum is not spent elsewhere: it joins the extra money for the next target, so the amount aimed at the target keeps growing. The debt avalanche picks the target with the highest APR (annual percentage rate). The debt snowball picks the target with the smallest balance. The only difference is the order.
Jordan’s debts
Section titled “Jordan’s debts”| Debt | Balance | APR | Monthly rate | Minimum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Credit card | $6,000 | 24% | 24 ÷ 12 = 2% | $150 |
| Store card | $1,200 | 18% | 18 ÷ 12 = 1.5% | $40 |
| Personal loan | $4,000 | 10% | 10 ÷ 12 ≈ 0.833% | $110 |
| Total | $11,200 | $300 |
Budget: $500 a month, so $500 − $300 = $200 extra at the start. To keep the arithmetic checkable, interest each month is the balance × APR ÷ 12, added before payments, the minimums stay fixed until a debt is paid off, and there is no new borrowing. This is the same convention the debt payoff calculator in “Try it” uses. Real cards usually charge interest on an average daily balance and recalculate minimums, as their agreements explain.
The order each method uses:
| Method | Target order |
|---|---|
| Avalanche | Credit card (24%) → store card (18%) → personal loan (10%) |
| Snowball | Store card ($1,200) → personal loan ($4,000) → card ($6,000) |
Example 1: both methods, month by month
Section titled “Example 1: both methods, month by month”Month 1, interest (same for both): $6,000 × 0.02 = $120 on the card; $1,200 × 0.015 = $18 on the store card; $4,000 × 0.10 ÷ 12 ≈ $33.33 on the loan.
| Month 1 ending balance | Avalanche (extra to card) | Snowball (extra to store card) |
|---|---|---|
| Credit card | $6,000 + $120 − $150 − $200 = $5,770 | $6,000 + $120 − $150 = $5,970 |
| Store card | $1,200 + $18 − $40 = $1,178 | $1,200 + $18 − $40 − $200 = $978 |
| Personal loan | $3,923.33 | $3,923.33 |
Month 2: the avalanche card goes to $5,770 × 1.02 − $150 − $200 = $5,535.40; the snowball store card goes to $978 × 1.015 − $40 − $200 = $752.67. The pattern continues every month: interest is added, minimums are paid, and the target gets the rest.
Here are the months when something changes, from running the same rules every month until all three reach zero:
| Event | Avalanche | Snowball |
|---|---|---|
| First debt paid off | Month 22 (card) | Month 6 (store card) |
| Second debt paid off | Month 23 (store card) | Month 17 (personal loan) |
| Last debt paid off | Month 28 (personal loan) | Month 29 (card) |
| Final payment | $77.42 | $201.67 |
| Total paid | 27 × $500 + $77.42 = $13,577.42 | 28 × $500 + $201.67 = $14,201.67 |
| Total interest | $13,577.42 − $11,200 = $2,377.42 | $14,201.67 − $11,200 = $3,001.67 |
In month 22 the avalanche card has only $69.84 left, which grows to about $71.24 with interest; its $150 minimum covers that and the rest spills onto the store card in the same month.
Interest by debt:
| Debt | Avalanche | Snowball |
|---|---|---|
| Credit card | $1,421.23 | $2,598.87 |
| Store card | $316.87 | $57.04 |
| Personal loan | $639.32 | $345.77 |
| Total | $2,377.42 | $3,001.68 (rounding: $3,001.67) |
The avalanche costs $624.25 less interest and finishes 29 − 28 = 1 month sooner. The snowball pays off its first debt 22 − 6 = 16 months earlier. Look at where the snowball’s extra interest comes from: the 24% card sits nearly untouched for 17 months while the cheaper debts get the extra money.
Example 2: what changes with a bigger budget
Section titled “Example 2: what changes with a bigger budget”Same debts, but Jordan puts $800 a month toward them: $800 − $300 = $500 extra.
| Budget $800 | Months | Total interest |
|---|---|---|
| Avalanche | 16 | $1,299.33 |
| Snowball | 17 | $1,715.48 |
| Difference | 1 | $416.15 |
The gap between methods is smaller in dollars than at $500, but the bigger effect is the budget itself: the avalanche at $800 costs $2,377.42 − $1,299.33 = $1,078.09 less than the avalanche at $500.
Example 3: the edge case, minimums only
Section titled “Example 3: the edge case, minimums only”Now the budget is exactly the $300 of minimums. There is no extra money until a debt is paid off, so for most of the time both methods pay the same amounts.
| Budget $300 | Months | Total interest |
|---|---|---|
| Avalanche | 59 | $6,294.31 |
| Snowball | 59 | $6,296.91 |
| Difference | 0 | $2.60 |
Both methods finish in month 59, and the order makes only a $2.60 difference. Compared with the $500 budget, paying only minimums costs $6,294.31 − $2,377.42 = $3,916.89 more interest and takes 59 − 28 = 31 more months. The size of the payment matters more than the order of payment.
The behavioural argument, described neutrally
Section titled “The behavioural argument, described neutrally”The arithmetic favours the avalanche whenever the rates differ: money aimed at the highest rate removes the most expensive balance first. In all three examples here, the avalanche cost the same or less interest than the snowball.
Supporters of the snowball accept that it can cost more. Their argument is about behaviour: paying off a whole account early gives a visible result, cuts the number of bills to track, and may help some people keep going until the end. In Example 1, Jordan’s first account closes in month 6 with the snowball and month 22 with the avalanche. Whether that earlier result is worth $624.25 here is a personal judgement, and a plan only saves money if it is followed. Some people mix the two, for example clearing one very small balance first and then switching to rate order.
Two points do not depend on which method is chosen: both need the minimum paid on every debt every month, and both depend on not adding new balances while paying down.
Try it
Section titled “Try it”Open the debt payoff calculator. It compares the snowball and the avalanche with the rules used above.
- Enter Jordan’s debts: 6000 at 24 with a 150 minimum, 1200 at 18 with 40, and 4000 at 10 with 110, and a budget of 500. It should show 29 months and about $3,002 for the snowball, and 28 months and about $2,377 for the avalanche (it rounds to whole dollars). Its tables list the payoff month of each debt.
- Change the budget to 800, then to 300, and compare with Examples 2 and 3.
- Try its default inputs: a store card ($1,200 at 19.99%, $35 minimum), a credit card ($4,500 at 26.99%, $95) and a personal loan ($7,000 at 11%, $140), $12,700 in total with $270 of minimums, and a $600 budget. Both finish in 25 months; the avalanche costs about $2,114 and the snowball about $2,207, a gap of about $92.94 before rounding. Notice that the store card is the smallest balance but not the highest rate.
Common mistakes
Section titled “Common mistakes”- Dropping a freed-up minimum. When a debt is paid off, both methods move its minimum to the next target. Spending it elsewhere slows either method.
- Ranking by monthly payment instead of APR or balance. The avalanche uses the rate; the snowball uses the balance. The minimum payment ranks neither.
- Ignoring promotional rates that end. A 0% balance that jumps to a high rate later changes the avalanche order when it does.
- Thinking the method matters more than the budget. In Example 3, the order was worth $2.60; the budget was worth thousands.
- Missing a minimum to speed up the target. Both methods assume every minimum is paid on time.
Real-world context
Section titled “Real-world context”Each debt’s statement or loan agreement lists the balance, the APR and the minimum or scheduled payment, which are the inputs for either method. Card statements also show a repayment box; Grace periods and minimum payments explains it. Instalment loans such as the personal loan here are amortizing, as How amortization works shows, so extra payments on them shorten the schedule.
Quick check
Section titled “Quick check”- A card with a $500 balance at 30% APR and a loan with a $3,000 balance at 6%: which is the avalanche target and which the snowball target?
Show the answer to question 1
The card is both. It has the higher rate (30% vs 6%) and the smaller balance ($500 vs $3,000), so the two methods agree.
- In that case, what is one month’s interest on each?
Show the answer to question 2
$12.50 on the card ($500 × 0.30 ÷ 12) and $15 on the loan ($3,000 × 0.06 ÷ 12). The loan charges more dollars because its balance is larger, but the card charges a higher rate on each dollar.
- Under the snowball, a $40 minimum frees up when the store card is paid off. Where does it go?
Show the answer to question 3
To the next target, along with the rest of the extra money. The total budget stays the same.
- When do the two methods pick the same targets?
Show the answer to question 4
When the smallest balance is also the highest rate at every step, so both pick the same target in the same order. Example 3 shows they can also come close when there is little extra money to aim.
Key takeaways
Section titled “Key takeaways”- Both methods pay every minimum and aim all extra money at one target; the avalanche targets the highest APR, the snowball the smallest balance.
- On Jordan’s hypothetical $11,200 with $500 a month, the avalanche took 28 months and $2,377.42 of interest; the snowball took 29 months and $3,001.67, but cleared its first debt 16 months earlier.
- The budget mattered more than the method: minimums only took 59 months and over $6,294 of interest either way.
- The case for the snowball is behavioural; the case for the avalanche is arithmetic. Both are described here, not recommended.
Next steps
Section titled “Next steps”- How amortization works: why extra principal on a loan saves interest.
- Comparing loan offers: what to compare before taking on a new loan.
- Run your own numbers in the debt payoff calculator.
For educational purposes only. This material does not provide investment advice.