Skip to content

Risk and diversification

By Investor Wisdom Daily Team·

Picture Maya (hypothetical). She has saved $10,000, and a friend at work keeps talking about one exciting company. She is tempted to put the whole amount into it. Her cousin Leo (also hypothetical) has the same $10,000 and the same enthusiasm, but he puts $500 into that company and spreads the rest across many others. A year later the company has fallen 60%. Maya has lost $6,000 and needs her remaining money to grow 150% just to get back to where she started. Leo has lost $300 and barely notices.

Both of them liked the same company. What separated them was not the idea, but how much they bet on it.

Every investor and every strategy has losing trades and losing years. The aim is not to avoid all losses, which is impossible, but to make sure no single loss, or bad stretch, can knock you out of the game. Two tools do most of that work. Position size controls how much any one idea can cost you. Diversification, spreading your money across many different investments, means that one company’s bad news cannot decide your whole outcome. Behind both is a piece of simple maths: losses hurt more than equal-sized gains help.

A drawdown is the fall from a peak in your account value to a later low. Losses and recoveries are not symmetrical. If you lose a fraction of your money, the gain you need to get back to even is 1 ÷ (1 − loss) − 1:

Loss Gain needed to get back to even
10% 11%
25% 33%
50% 100%
75% 300%

Work one through: lose 50% of $10,000 and you have $5,000. To get back to $10,000, that $5,000 has to double, a 100% gain. The bigger the loss, the faster the required gain explodes. This is why controlling large losses matters more than finding large gains.

Position size is how much of your money goes into one holding. A simple and common rule is to decide in advance how much of the account you are willing to lose if a trade goes wrong, and size the position so that, if the price falls to your exit point (your stop), you lose about that much. A stop does not guarantee your exit price: if a stock gaps down, the order can fill well below the stop (see Order types), so the loss can be larger.

Worked example 1: sizing a position from a risk limit

Section titled “Worked example 1: sizing a position from a risk limit”

Illustrative example: with a $10,000 account and a 1% risk limit, you accept losing $100 on one trade. If you buy at $50 with a stop at $45, you risk $5 a share, so you buy 20 shares.

Step by step:

  1. Risk budget: $10,000 × 1% = $100.
  2. Risk per share: $50 entry − $45 stop = $5.
  3. Shares: $100 ÷ $5 = 20 shares, a position worth 20 × $50 = $1,000.

Notice that the position is worth 10% of the account, but the planned risk is only 1%. Position size and risk are not the same number.

Now suppose bad news comes out overnight and the stock opens at $42, below the $45 stop. A stop order becomes a market order and fills near $42. The loss is 20 × ($50 − $42) = $160, or 1.6% of the account, not the planned 1%. Sizing still did its job (the damage is limited), but the plan’s number is a target, not a guarantee.

Many rule-based strategies use this idea: each trade risks a set fraction of the account, with a cap on how large any one position can be.

Even good strategies have runs of losses. Compare risking 1% and 10% of the account per trade over ten losses in a row, starting from $10,000:

Risk per trade Account after 10 straight losses Drawdown Gain needed to recover
1% about $9,044 about 9.6% about 10.6%
10% about $3,487 about 65.1% about 187%

The calculation is $10,000 × 0.99¹⁰ for the 1% row and $10,000 × 0.90¹⁰ for the 10% row. Ten losses at 1% is an annoying stretch. Ten losses at 10% is close to the end of the account.

Different companies, industries and types of investment do not all rise and fall together. Spreading money across several of them, diversification, reduces the damage any single one can do.

  • Many stocks rather than one or two.
  • Several industries and sectors, because companies in the same sector often move together.
  • Some money outside the stock market for needs in the next few years.

Return to Maya and Leo. Each has $10,000, and the company they both like falls 60%.

Maya: one stock Leo: 20 equal positions
Money in the company $10,000 $10,000 ÷ 20 = $500
Loss from a 60% fall $6,000 $300
Loss as share of the account 60% 3%
Gain needed on the rest to recover 150% about 3.1%

Leo’s other 19 holdings might rise or fall too, but no single one of them can do to him what one company did to Maya.

Diversification does not prevent losses when the whole market falls, but it reduces the risk of a single company’s bad news ruining your plan. Owning 20 stocks that all sit in one industry gives much less protection than the count suggests, because those companies tend to fall together.

Money you will need soon, for rent, bills or an emergency, does not belong in individual stocks. Prices can fall sharply and stay down for years.

Open the ROI calculator. Enter an investment of $10,000 that ends at $5,000 and note the return: −50%. Now enter $5,000 growing to $10,000 and note the return: +100%. Same dollars, very different percentages. Then try $10,000 ending at $9,044, the 1% losing-streak result above, and compare it with $3,487.

  1. “A 50% loss and a 50% gain cancel out.” They don’t. $10,000 that falls 50% and then rises 50% ends at $7,500. Recovery always needs a bigger percentage than the loss.
  2. Confusing position size with risk. A $1,000 position with a nearby stop can risk less than a $300 position with no exit plan. Decide the loss you accept first, then the size.
  3. Treating a stop as a guaranteed price. Gaps can push the fill well past the stop, as the $42 example shows. Size so that a gap is painful, not fatal.
  4. Counting holdings instead of exposures. Ten technology stocks, or three funds that own the same large companies, can behave like one big bet. Check what you own underneath the names.
  5. Raising risk after a losing run to “win it back”. Bigger bets during a drawdown are how a bad stretch becomes a ruined account.

The US Securities and Exchange Commission’s guide to asset allocation puts it simply: “The practice of spreading money among different investments to reduce risk is known as diversification.” (SEC, Beginners’ Guide to Asset Allocation, Diversification, and Rebalancing, dated 27 August 2009.) The same guide reminds readers that “All investments involve some degree of risk.”

You can see these ideas in documents you already receive. A fund’s fact sheet lists its number of holdings and its largest positions, which tells you how concentrated it is. A brokerage statement shows each position’s market value, so you can work out what percentage of your account each one represents.

1. An account falls 40%. Roughly what gain is needed to get back to even?

Answer to question 1

About 67%. The formula is 1 ÷ (1 − 0.40) − 1 ≈ 0.667.

2. You have $20,000 and a 2% risk limit. You plan to buy at $80 with a stop at $72. How many shares fit the plan?

Answer to question 2

50 shares. The risk budget is $20,000 × 2% = $400, the risk per share is $80 − $72 = $8, and $400 ÷ $8 = 50. A gap below $72 could still make the loss larger.

3. You own 15 stocks, all banks. Are you well diversified?

Answer to question 3

Not very. Companies in one sector often move together, so a problem for the industry can hit all 15 at once. Spreading across sectors and asset types gives more protection.

4. $10,000 falls 50% and then rises 50%. What is it worth?

Answer to question 4

$7,500. The fall leaves $5,000, and a 50% gain on $5,000 adds $2,500.

  • Large losses need much larger gains to recover; avoiding them comes first.
  • Decide how much you can lose on one idea before you start, and size positions to match.
  • A stop limits planned risk but does not guarantee the exit price.
  • Spread your money so that no single company or sector decides your outcome.
  • Keep money you need soon out of individual stocks.

Key terms

For educational purposes only. This material does not provide investment advice.