Mortgage points and break-even
By Investor Wisdom Daily Team·
Pay now or pay monthly
Section titled “Pay now or pay monthly”Maria, a hypothetical buyer, gets two quotes from the same lender for the same 30-year loan. One has a lower rate and a fee at closing labelled “points”. The other has no points and a slightly higher rate. The lower rate saves money every month; the points cost money on day one. Which is cheaper depends almost entirely on one thing she cannot know for sure: how long she will keep the loan.
This lesson explains discount points and lender credits, works out the simple break-even month, uses the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s own example, and shows why the answer changes with the time horizon. Apart from the CFPB example, all people, loans and rates are hypothetical.
The idea in one paragraph
Section titled “The idea in one paragraph”Discount points are upfront fees paid at closing in exchange for a lower interest rate. The CFPB explains that one point costs 1% of the loan amount, so one point on a $100,000 loan is $1,000, and points can come in fractions such as 0.125 or 1.375 (CFPB, as of November 2026). How much the rate drops per point varies by lender, loan type and market conditions. Lender credits work the other way: the borrower accepts a higher rate and the lender pays money toward closing costs. The same CFPB page says lender credits appear as a negative number in Section J of the Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure, and the CFPB’s Loan Estimate explainer explains what an amount on the points line means (as of November 2026).
The simple break-even
Section titled “The simple break-even”Break-even months = cost of the points ÷ monthly saving in principal and interest
Before the break-even month, the points have cost more than the lower payment has saved. After it, the borrower is ahead, as long as the loan is still in place. The monthly payment comes from the amortization formula.
Example 1: the CFPB’s $180,000 example
Section titled “Example 1: the CFPB’s $180,000 example”The CFPB page describes a $180,000, 30-year fixed-rate loan with three options from one lender (CFPB, as of November 2026). The payments below are worked out with the payment formula.
| Option | Rate | Points or credit | Principal and interest | Change per month |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No points | 5.000% | none | $966.28 | none |
| Pay 0.375 points | 4.875% | $675 paid at closing | $952.57 | $13.71 less |
| Take 0.375 credit | 5.125% | $675 received at closing | $980.08 | $13.80 more |
- Cost of the points: 0.375% × $180,000 = $675.
- Monthly saving: $966.28 − $952.57 = $13.71, which the CFPB rounds to “about $14”.
- Break-even: $675 ÷ $13.71 ≈ 49.2 months, a little over four years. After 49 payments the saving is 49 × $13.71 = $671.79, just short of $675; after 50 it is $685.50.
The lender credit is the mirror image. A borrower taking the credit would receive $675 toward closing costs and pay $13.80 more a month, so the credit is used up after about $675 ÷ $13.80 ≈ 48.9 months. Keep the loan longer than that and the credit has cost more than it gave.
Example 2: shortest, longest and most likely horizon
Section titled “Example 2: shortest, longest and most likely horizon”The CFPB suggests getting quotes with and without points and credits and comparing the total cost over the shortest, longest and most likely time the loan will be kept. Using Example 1’s figures and three hypothetical horizons:
| Kept for | Pay 0.375 points: saving − $675 | Take 0.375 credit: $675 − extra paid |
|---|---|---|
| 3 years (36 months) | 36 × $13.71 − $675 = −$181.44 | $675 − 36 × $13.80 = +$178.20 |
| 7 years (84 months) | 84 × $13.71 − $675 = +$476.64 | $675 − 84 × $13.80 = −$484.20 |
| 30 years (360 months) | 360 × $13.71 − $675 = +$4,260.60 | $675 − 360 × $13.80 = −$4,293.00 |
A plus sign means that choice came out ahead of the no-points loan; a minus sign means it came out behind. Over three years the points lose $181.44 and the credit gains $178.20. By seven years the order has flipped, and over the full term the gap is in the thousands. No single option wins at every horizon; the comparison is only as good as the guess about how long the loan will last.
Example 3: a larger loan, and what else the cash could do
Section titled “Example 3: a larger loan, and what else the cash could do”A hypothetical lender quotes a $300,000, 30-year loan at a hypothetical 6.5% with no points, or 6.25% for one point.
- Cost: 1% × $300,000 = $3,000.
- Payments: $1,896.20 at 6.5% and $1,847.15 at 6.25%, a saving of $49.05 a month.
- Break-even: $3,000 ÷ $49.05 ≈ 61.2 months, just over five years.
- If the home is sold, or the loan refinanced, after four years (48 months): 48 × $49.05 − $3,000 = −$645.60. The points were not recovered.
The same $3,000 has other uses. Added to the down payment instead, it would shrink the loan to $297,000; at 6.5% the payment falls to $1,877.24, which is $18.96 a month lower. That is a smaller monthly saving than the points give, but the $3,000 is not spent: it becomes home equity, which can be recovered at a sale if the price covers the loan and selling costs, while the cost of points is not recovered. Kept as cash, it could also stay in an emergency fund or cover moving costs and repairs. A fair comparison counts what the cash would have done otherwise.
What the simple break-even leaves out
Section titled “What the simple break-even leaves out”- Selling or refinancing early. Points only pay off if the loan lasts past break-even. A move, a sale or a refinance ends the saving.
- The time value of money. $675 today is worth more than $13.71 a month spread over four years, so the true break-even is a little later than the simple one.
- Faster paydown. At a lower rate, a little more of each payment goes to principal, so the balance falls slightly faster. The simple formula ignores this small extra benefit.
- The other use of the cash. As Example 3 shows, the money could go to the down payment, reserves or other costs.
- Comparing like with like. The CFPB suggests comparing against the same lender’s zero-point rate for the same loan type, so that only the points differ.
Try it
Section titled “Try it”Open the mortgage calculator. Set the property taxes, insurance and HOA dues to $0 so the result is principal and interest only.
- Enter a $225,000 price and $45,000 down (a $180,000 loan and exactly 20% down, so no PMI), 5% for 30 years: $966.28 a month.
- Change the rate to 4.875%: $952.57, the 0.375-point option. Then 5.125%: $980.08, the lender-credit option.
- Divide $675 by the difference and compare the answer with Example 1.
The refinance calculator applies the same break-even idea to the closing costs of a new loan.
Common mistakes
Section titled “Common mistakes”- Looking only at the rate. A lower rate bought with points costs cash at closing; compare rate and points together.
- Assuming the loan will last 30 years. Many loans end early through a sale or a refinance; check the break-even against realistic horizons.
- Comparing quotes from different loan types or days. The rate per point differs by lender, loan type and market; compare against the same lender’s zero-point rate.
- Forgetting that credits cost money too. A lender credit lowers closing costs but raises every monthly payment.
Real-world context
Section titled “Real-world context”Points and lender credits are listed on the Loan Estimate, so two quotes can be compared line by line before choosing. The CFPB’s points and lender credits page explains where lender credits appear, and its Loan Estimate explainer explains the points line.
Quick check
Section titled “Quick check”- How much do 1.5 points cost on a $250,000 loan?
Show the answer to question 1
$3,750. 1.5% × $250,000.
- If those points lower the payment by $50 a month, what is the simple break-even?
Show the answer to question 2
75 months, or 6.25 years. $3,750 ÷ $50.
- The borrower sells after five years (60 months). How far ahead or behind are the points?
Show the answer to question 3
$750 behind. 60 × $50 = $3,000 saved, minus $3,750 paid.
- Why does a lender credit tend to look better the shorter the expected horizon?
Show the answer to question 4
The credit is received in full at closing, while its cost, a higher payment, builds up month by month. The sooner the loan ends, the less of that higher payment is paid.
Key takeaways
Section titled “Key takeaways”- One point costs 1% of the loan amount and buys a rate reduction that varies by lender, loan type and market.
- Simple break-even = cost of points ÷ monthly P&I saving. In the CFPB’s $180,000 example, $675 ÷ $13.71 ≈ 49 months.
- Lender credits are the reverse trade: cash at closing for a higher payment.
- Points pay off only if the loan is kept past break-even; compare the options over the shortest, longest and most likely horizon, and count the other uses of the cash.
Next steps
Section titled “Next steps”- How much house can I afford?: the full monthly payment and debt-to-income limits.
- Comparing loan offers by APR and total cost: APR, fees and total cost side by side.
- Try the rates in the mortgage calculator.
For educational purposes only. This material does not provide investment advice.