Skip to content

How much house can I afford?

By Investor Wisdom Daily Team·

Sam and Alex, a hypothetical couple, earn $8,000 a month before taxes. A lender’s pre-approval letter suggests they could borrow far more than they expected. Their own spreadsheet, with childcare, savings and a car that will need replacing, says something smaller. Both numbers can be right, because they answer two different questions.

The first is what a lender may approve. The second is what a household budget can carry. This lesson works through both with hypothetical numbers, lists every bill that makes up a monthly housing payment, and shows how to work backward from a monthly payment to a loan amount and a price. All people, incomes, prices, interest rates and bills here are hypothetical.

Lenders look at a debt-to-income ratio (DTI): all monthly debt payments divided by gross monthly income, which is pay before taxes and deductions. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) gives the example of $2,000 of monthly debt on $6,000 of gross income, a DTI of about 33%, and notes that “different loan products and lenders will have different DTI limits” (CFPB, as of November 2026). A lender’s limit is a ceiling for approving a loan. It does not know about the household’s other spending, savings goals or emergency fund, so it is not a target. The budget view starts from those instead.

Each loan program and investor sets its own maximum DTI. One example is Fannie Mae, which buys many conventional mortgages. Its Selling Guide sets these maximums for the total ratio (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-02, as of November 2026):

Underwriting route Maximum total DTI
Manually underwritten loans 36% of stable monthly income
Manually underwritten, with conditions Up to 45% if credit score and reserve requirements are met
Desktop Underwriter (automated) casefiles 50%

These are one investor’s maximums for its conventional loans. Other loan types and lenders use different limits, and a loan right at a maximum leaves no slack in the household budget.

What counts as a monthly obligation matters as much as the limit. In Fannie Mae’s guide the total includes the new housing payment (principal, interest, property taxes, homeowners insurance and association dues on a principal residence), installment debts with more than ten months left, revolving debts such as credit cards, lease payments, alimony or child support, and other recurring obligations. The CFPB adds that a lender must consider a borrower’s DTI or residual income for a Qualified Mortgage (CFPB, as of November 2026).

The payment a lender counts is more than principal and interest. Each piece below is a separate bill, even when the lender collects it all in one monthly payment:

  • Principal and interest (P&I): the loan payment from the amortization formula.
  • Property taxes: a bill set by the local government. Divide the yearly amount by 12.
  • Homeowners insurance: the yearly premium divided by 12.
  • Private mortgage insurance (PMI): on a conventional loan, the CFPB says PMI is generally required with a down payment under 20% of the price, usually as a monthly premium added to the payment, sometimes paid upfront, or both (CFPB, as of November 2026).
  • Homeowners association (HOA) dues: a monthly charge in many condos and planned communities.

Maintenance and repairs are not part of the lender’s payment, but the household still pays them, which is one reason the budget view usually lands lower.

Sam and Alex have $8,000 of gross monthly income. Their other debts are a car payment of $400, student loans of $250 and a $100 card minimum: $400 + $250 + $100 = $750 a month. A home they like would carry a full housing payment of $2,200.

  • Housing payment alone: $2,200 ÷ $8,000 = 27.5% of gross income.
  • Total DTI with the new payment: ($2,200 + $750) ÷ $8,000 ≈ 36.9%.

That is just above the 36% manual-underwriting maximum and below the 45% and 50% figures. Turning each maximum into dollars shows how much housing payment it leaves room for:

Maximum total DTI All debts allowed Room for housing after $750 of other debts
36% 0.36 × $8,000 = $2,880 $2,880 − $750 = $2,130
45% 0.45 × $8,000 = $3,600 $3,600 − $750 = $2,850
50% 0.50 × $8,000 = $4,000 $4,000 − $750 = $3,250

The same income supports anything from $2,130 to $3,250 of housing, depending on the route. Paying off the $100 card minimum would add $100 of room at every level, because lenders count the payment, not the balance.

Example 2: working back from a budget to a price

Section titled “Example 2: working back from a budget to a price”

Sam and Alex build their budget first, counting childcare, saving and an emergency fund (see Emergency fund sizing), and decide they are comfortable with $2,400 a month for all housing costs. They estimate property taxes of $350 a month and insurance of $150 a month for homes in their area, with no HOA.

Step 1: room for principal and interest. $2,400 − $350 − $150 = $1,900.

Step 2: turn the payment into a loan amount. The payment formula runs in reverse:

Loan = Payment × (1 − (1 + r)^−n) ÷ r

At a hypothetical 6.5% rate for 30 years, r = 6.5% ÷ 12 ≈ 0.5417% a month and n = 360. So the loan is $1,900 × (1 − 1.0054167^−360) ÷ 0.0054167 ≈ $300,600.56. Checking forward: $300,600 at 6.5% for 30 years has a payment of $1,900.00.

Step 3: add the down payment. With $80,000 saved for a down payment, the price is about $300,600 + $80,000 ≈ $380,600. The down payment is $80,000 ÷ $380,600 ≈ 21.0% of the price, so on a conventional loan PMI would generally not apply. A price that pushed the down payment under 20% would add PMI and shrink the room for P&I.

Step 4: check it against the lender view. ($2,400 + $750) ÷ $8,000 ≈ 39.4%. The budget-based payment is above the 36% manual figure and inside the 45% and 50% figures, and well below the largest approval from Example 1. The budget, not the lender’s maximum, set the price.

A different hypothetical buyer looks at a $300,000 condo with HOA dues of $200 a month, property taxes of $300 a month and insurance of $125 a month, at a hypothetical 6.5% rate for 30 years and a hypothetical PMI premium of 0.5% of the loan a year.

Monthly cost 5% down ($15,000) 20% down ($60,000)
Loan amount $285,000 $240,000
Principal and interest $1,801.39 $1,516.96
PMI $118.75 $0.00
Property taxes $300.00 $300.00
Homeowners insurance $125.00 $125.00
HOA dues $200.00 $200.00
Total monthly payment $2,545.14 $2,141.96

With 5% down, P&I is $1,801.39 and PMI is $285,000 × 0.5% ÷ 12 = $118.75. P&I is only about 70.8% of the total; the other bills add $743.75. The extra $45,000 of down payment lowers the monthly total by $403.18, partly through a smaller loan and partly by removing PMI. A quote for “the mortgage payment” that shows P&I alone would understate this buyer’s housing cost by about 29%.

Open the mortgage calculator. It adds P&I, property taxes, insurance, HOA dues and PMI (when the down payment is under 20%) into one monthly payment, and rounds each part to the cent.

  • Enter a $450,000 price, $90,000 down, 6.5% for 30 years, $4,950 a year of property taxes, $1,800 a year of insurance and $0 HOA. The loan is $360,000, P&I is $2,275.44, and the total is $2,837.94 ($2,275.44 + $412.50 + $150). The down payment is exactly 20%, so no PMI is added. The calculator may open with a current market rate instead of 6.5%, so type the rate in.
  • Its “Max price for a monthly budget” mode works backward like Example 2. Its answer can differ from Example 2, because when the property-taxes or insurance field is left at its starting value, that mode scales the bill with the price.

Then open the debt-to-income calculator. Its starting inputs are $7,500 of gross income, $2,100 of housing and $450, $200, $150 and $100 of other payments. It shows a housing ratio of 28.0% and a total (back-end) ratio of $3,000 ÷ $7,500 = 40.0%. The calculator draws its own guide lines; compare the result with the limits of the loan program actually being considered.

To compare owning with keeping on renting over several years, the rent vs buy calculator adds the costs this lesson leaves out, such as maintenance.

  • Treating the approval amount as a target. A lender’s maximum DTI is a ceiling for one program, and it ignores savings, childcare and repairs.
  • Budgeting on principal and interest alone. In Example 3, the other bills added $743.75 a month to the P&I.
  • Using net pay in the ratio. DTI divides by gross income, before taxes and deductions; a budget runs on take-home pay.
  • Forgetting PMI below 20% down. It raises the payment and lowers the price a fixed budget can reach.
  • Leaving out small debts. A $100 minimum payment uses $100 of room under every DTI limit.

A lender’s Loan Estimate lists the loan amount, the interest rate and the projected payments; the CFPB’s Loan Estimate explainer walks through the form. On a fixed-rate loan the principal and interest stay the same, but property taxes, insurance premiums and HOA dues are set by others and can change after purchase, so the full housing cost is an estimate, not a fixed number.

  1. A household has $6,000 of gross monthly income, $600 of other debt payments and a $1,800 proposed housing payment. What is the total DTI?
Show the answer to question 1

40%. ($1,800 + $600) ÷ $6,000 = 0.40.

  1. For that household, how much housing payment fits under a 36% maximum total DTI?
Show the answer to question 2

$1,560. 0.36 × $6,000 = $2,160 of total debts, minus $600 of other debts.

  1. A payment has $1,500 of principal and interest, $250 of property taxes and $100 of insurance, with 25% down and no HOA. What is the full monthly housing payment?
Show the answer to question 3

$1,850. $1,500 + $250 + $100. With 25% down on a conventional loan, PMI would generally not apply.

  1. Why can two people with the same income get very different answers to “how much house can I afford”?
Show the answer to question 4

Because other debts use up DTI room, the limit depends on the loan program, and the budget view depends on each household’s other spending and savings, which a DTI ratio does not see.

  • DTI is all monthly debt payments divided by gross monthly income; limits differ by loan program and lender.
  • Fannie Mae’s maximums are 36% (manual), up to 45% with conditions, and 50% (automated), as of November 2026; these are ceilings, not targets.
  • The full housing payment includes P&I, property taxes, insurance, PMI under 20% down, and HOA dues.
  • Working back: P&I room × (1 − (1 + r)^−n) ÷ r gives the loan; add the down payment to get the price. $1,900 at a hypothetical 6.5% for 30 years supports about $300,600.

For educational purposes only. This material does not provide investment advice.