Fund overlap
By Investor Wisdom Daily Team·
Three funds, one bet?
Section titled “Three funds, one bet?”Jordan (a hypothetical investor) owns three funds: a broad large-company index fund, a “growth” fund and a technology fund. Three funds, three different names, three fact sheets. Jordan feels well spread out. Then a single large company has a bad quarter and all three funds drop on the same day.
The names were different, but much of what sat inside them was the same. This lesson shows how to measure that: how much two funds overlap, and how much of your money really rides on one company once you add the funds together.
The idea in one paragraph
Section titled “The idea in one paragraph”A fund is a basket of holdings, and each holding has a weight: the percentage of the fund’s assets in it. Two funds overlap when they hold the same companies. A simple way to measure overlap is to take each company both funds hold, keep the smaller of its two weights, and add those up. The result runs from 0% (nothing in common) to 100% (identical baskets). Your effective exposure to a company is what you get by multiplying each fund’s weight in that company by your share in that fund, and adding across funds. It answers the practical question: “If this one company falls 20%, how much of my portfolio falls with it?”
Risk and diversification explains why spreading money across many independent holdings lowers risk. This lesson is about checking whether your funds actually do that.
Why overlap happens
Section titled “Why overlap happens”Many stock indexes weight companies by size (market value), so the largest companies take the biggest weights. A broad index, a growth index and a sector index can all end up led by the same few giants. Investor.gov’s ETF page also cautions that “some ETFs are less diverse than others. They may have fewer investments or may even track the performance of a single stock” (Investor.gov: ETFs, accessed 19 November 2026).
Overlap is not wrong in itself. A fund that holds the whole market will overlap with almost everything. The problem comes when you add a second or third fund believing it diversifies you, and it mostly repeats what you already own.
Worked example 1: overlap from two top-five lists
Section titled “Worked example 1: overlap from two top-five lists”Two hypothetical funds publish their five largest holdings. The companies (Alpha, Beta and so on) are invented.
| Company | Fund P weight | Fund Q weight | Smaller of the two |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alpha | 7% | 10% | 7% |
| Beta | 6% | 8% | 6% |
| Gamma | 5% | 3% | 3% |
| Delta | 4% | not in top 5 | — |
| Epsilon | 3% | not in top 5 | — |
| Zeta | not in top 5 | 6% | — |
| Eta | not in top 5 | 5% | — |
| Total | 25% | 32% | 16% |
Step by step:
- List the companies that appear in both lists: Alpha, Beta and Gamma.
- For each, keep the smaller weight: 7% (Alpha), 6% (Beta), 3% (Gamma).
- Add them: 7 + 6 + 3 = 16%.
So at least 16% of each fund is the same money in the same companies. “At least”, because this used only the top five holdings. If Delta also sits further down Fund Q’s list, the true overlap is higher. Overlap measured from partial lists is a lower bound: adding more shared holdings can only raise it.
Why the smaller weight? Fund P has 7% in Alpha and Fund Q has 10%. The 7% is common ground; Fund Q’s extra 3 points are its own bet, not shared.
Worked example 2: your real exposure in a 50/50 mix
Section titled “Worked example 2: your real exposure in a 50/50 mix”Jordan puts $20,000 into the two funds, $10,000 each (50% and 50%). Effective exposure to each company is your weight in each fund times that fund’s weight in the company, added up:
- Alpha: 0.5 × 7% + 0.5 × 10% = 8.5%, or $20,000 × 8.5% = $1,700.
- Beta: 0.5 × 6% + 0.5 × 8% = 7%, or $1,400.
- Gamma: 0.5 × 5% + 0.5 × 3% = 4%, or $800.
Together these three companies are 8.5 + 7 + 4 = 19.5% of Jordan’s money, $3,900. Two funds that may hold hundreds of stocks between them still put nearly a fifth of the portfolio on three names.
Worked example 3: adding a sector fund
Section titled “Worked example 3: adding a sector fund”Jordan adds a hypothetical technology fund, Fund R, whose two largest holdings are Alpha at 20% and Beta at 15%. The $20,000 is now split 40% Fund P, 40% Fund Q and 20% Fund R ($4,000 in R).
- Alpha: 0.4 × 7% + 0.4 × 10% + 0.2 × 20% = 2.8 + 4 + 4 = 10.8%, or $2,160.
- Beta: 0.4 × 6% + 0.4 × 8% + 0.2 × 15% = 2.4 + 3.2 + 3 = 8.6%, or $1,720.
Alpha and Beta together are now 10.8 + 8.6 = 19.4% of the portfolio. Adding a third fund did not spread Jordan out; it pushed the single largest exposure up from 8.5% to 10.8%. If Alpha fell 20%, the portfolio would lose about 2.2% from Alpha alone, before anything else moved.
Edge cases: 100% and 0%
Section titled “Edge cases: 100% and 0%”- Two funds following the same index hold the same companies at the same weights, so the sum of the smaller weights is 100%. Owning both adds a second fee line and a second account entry, not diversification. Their costs and tracking may still differ (see Expense ratios and tracking difference).
- A stock fund and a bond fund usually share no holdings at all, so their overlap is 0%. That is the kind of difference Asset allocation basics builds on.
Most real pairs fall between these extremes, and the number you get depends heavily on how complete the holdings lists are.
Effective concentration: how many bets do you really have?
Section titled “Effective concentration: how many bets do you really have?”Counting holdings can mislead. A portfolio with four holdings weighted 40%, 30%, 20% and 10% behaves less like four equal bets than its count suggests. One common measure (the Herfindahl-Hirschman index) squares each weight (as a decimal) and adds them:
0.4² + 0.3² + 0.2² + 0.1² = 0.16 + 0.09 + 0.04 + 0.01 = 0.30.
Dividing 1 by that sum gives the effective number of holdings: 1 ÷ 0.30 ≈ 3.33. Four equal weights of 25% would give 4 × 0.25² = 0.25, and 1 ÷ 0.25 = 4. The more lopsided the weights, the fewer “real” bets you have. You can apply the same calculation to your effective exposures once you have added your funds together.
Try it by hand
Section titled “Try it by hand”There is no overlap calculator on this site yet, so this is a pencil-and-paper exercise:
- For each fund you own, write down its largest holdings and their weights from its fact sheet or holdings list, and note the date those holdings are “as of”.
- For any two funds, list shared companies and add the smaller weights. That is their overlap (a lower bound if the lists are partial).
- For each shared company, multiply each fund’s weight by your share in that fund and add across funds. Compare the largest result with how much you would be comfortable having in one company.
A spreadsheet with one row per company and one column per fund makes step 3 quick.
Common mistakes
Section titled “Common mistakes”- Counting funds instead of exposures. Three funds can hold the same leaders, as example 3 showed.
- Treating a top-ten overlap as the full answer. Partial lists understate overlap; full holdings lists give a better figure.
- Mixing dates. Holdings change. Comparing one fund’s list from March with another’s from September can give a misleading answer.
- Assuming overlap means “bad”. A broad index fund will overlap with nearly any other stock fund. The question is whether the extra fund adds anything you lack.
- Forgetting the money you hold directly. If you also own a company’s shares outright, add that to its effective exposure.
Real-world context
Section titled “Real-world context”Funds publish their holdings: fact sheets typically list the largest positions and their weights, and many fund websites post fuller lists with an “as of” date. Investor.gov describes an ETF’s combined holdings as its portfolio and says “Each ETF share represents an investor’s part ownership of the ETF’s portfolio” (Investor.gov: ETFs, accessed 19 November 2026). That ownership is exactly why a company’s weight inside a fund becomes part of your own exposure. All funds and companies in this lesson are hypothetical.
Quick check
Section titled “Quick check”- Fund X holds three companies at 5%, 4% and 3%. Fund Y holds the same three at 2%, 6% and 3%. What is their overlap across these holdings?
Answer to question 1
Take the smaller weight for each company: 2 + 4 + 3 = 9%.
- You hold 60% in Fund X and 40% in Fund Y. Fund X has 5% in one company and Fund Y has 2%. What is your effective exposure to that company?
Answer to question 2
0.6 × 5% + 0.4 × 2% = 3% + 0.8% = 3.8% of your portfolio.
- Your portfolio is $50,000. In dollars, how much is that 3.8% exposure?
Answer to question 3
$50,000 × 3.8% = $1,900.
- Your overlap estimate uses only each fund’s top ten holdings. Is the true overlap likely higher or lower?
Answer to question 4
Equal or higher. Adding more shared holdings can only add to the sum of the smaller weights, so a top-ten figure is a lower bound.
Key takeaways
Section titled “Key takeaways”- Overlap between two funds is the sum, over shared holdings, of the smaller of the two weights: 0% means nothing shared, 100% means identical.
- Effective exposure to a company is each fund’s weight in it times your share in that fund, added across funds.
- Adding funds with the same leaders can raise, not lower, your largest single exposure.
- Overlap from partial holdings lists is a lower bound; check the “as of” dates.
- The effective number of holdings (1 divided by the sum of squared weights) shows how many real bets you hold.
Next steps
Section titled “Next steps”- Expense ratios and tracking difference: what owning two similar funds costs.
- Risk and diversification: why independent bets reduce risk.
- Asset allocation basics: set the stock, bond and cash mix first.
Key terms
For educational purposes only. This material does not provide investment advice.