Calls and puts: rights, obligations and payoffs
By Investor Wisdom Daily Team·
Two people, one $200 contract
Section titled “Two people, one $200 contract”Sam and Priya, two hypothetical investors, are looking at the same fictional company, Maple Co, whose shares trade at $50. Sam pays $200 for a contract that lets him buy 100 Maple shares at $55 any time in the next two months. Priya is the person on the other side: she receives Sam’s $200 and promises to deliver 100 shares at $55 if Sam asks.
If Maple ends the two months at $50, Sam has lost his $200 and Priya keeps it. If Maple jumps to $70, Sam’s contract is worth $1,500 and Priya owes the difference. If Maple doubles to $100, Priya’s “easy $200” turns into a loss of $4,300. Same contract, two very different risk profiles. This lesson shows why, with numbers you can follow on paper.
The idea in one paragraph
Section titled “The idea in one paragraph”An option is a contract that gives its buyer (also called the holder) a right, and puts an obligation on its seller (also called the writer). A call gives the buyer the right, but not the obligation, to buy the underlying shares at a fixed price. A put gives the buyer the right, but not the obligation, to sell them at that fixed price. The fixed price is the strike price. The right lasts until the expiration date, the last day the contract is valid. The buyer pays the seller a price for the contract, called the premium. If the buyer uses the right, that is exercise; the seller who is picked to fulfil it receives an assignment and must sell (for a call) or buy (for a put) at the strike. The underlying is the asset the option refers to, here a stock.
As FINRA puts it, calls convey “the right, but not the obligation, to buy shares”, and puts “the right, but not the obligation, to sell shares” (FINRA, options).
The 100-share multiplier
Section titled “The 100-share multiplier”Option prices are quoted per share, but a contract covers more than one share. FINRA states that “a standard-size options contract is equal to 100 shares of the underlying security” (same page, accessed 2026-11-19). So a quoted premium of $2.00 costs 2 × 100 = $200 for one contract, and one contract on a $50 stock controls shares worth 50 × 100 = $5,000. Contracts can be adjusted after some corporate events, so read the contract terms; this lesson uses standard contracts.
Forgetting the multiplier is the most common way beginners misjudge an option’s cost or risk by a factor of 100.
Who has the right, who has the obligation
Section titled “Who has the right, who has the obligation”| Buyer (holder) | Seller (writer) | |
|---|---|---|
| Call | Right to buy at the strike | Must sell at the strike if assigned |
| Put | Right to sell at the strike | Must buy at the strike if assigned |
| Premium | Pays it | Receives it |
| Best case | Call: no fixed cap. Put: large but limited | The premium received |
| Worst case | Loses the whole premium | Call: no fixed limit. Put: large |
FINRA summarises the two sides: “for the purchaser of an option, the premium paid is your maximum loss”, and “for the seller of an option, the premium you receive at the time of the sale is your maximum profit” (FINRA, options).
Payoff at expiration: the one rule
Section titled “Payoff at expiration: the one rule”At expiration, an option is worth only what exercising it would give:
- A call is worth the stock price minus the strike, or zero if that is negative.
- A put is worth the strike minus the stock price, or zero if that is negative.
The buyer’s profit is that value minus the premium paid. The seller’s profit is the premium received minus that value. Multiply by 100 for one contract. Everything below is this rule applied to different numbers. The examples ignore commissions, bid-ask spreads and taxes, and look only at the moment of expiration (before then, an option also has time value, covered in the next lesson).
Example 1: buying a call
Section titled “Example 1: buying a call”Strike $55, premium $2.00 per share, so $200 for one contract. The stock is at $50 today.
Breakeven is the strike plus the premium: $55 + $2 = $57. Below $57 at expiration, the buyer loses money; above it, the buyer profits.
| Stock at expiration | Call value per share | Profit per share | Profit per contract |
|---|---|---|---|
| $40 | $0 | −$2.00 | −$200 |
| $50 | $0 | −$2.00 | −$200 |
| $55 | $0 | −$2.00 | −$200 |
| $57 | $2 | $0 | $0 |
| $60 | $5 | $3.00 | $300 |
| $70 | $15 | $13.00 | $1,300 |
Three things to notice:
- The stock can stay flat, rise a little or fall a lot, and the result is the same: the full $200 is gone. The buyer needs the stock above $57, not just “up”.
- At $70, the $1,300 profit is 650% of the $200 paid. Someone holding 100 shares bought at $50 would have gained 40% on $5,000 for the same move. That leverage works in both directions: the option buyer also loses 100% in the many outcomes where the share owner loses little or nothing.
- There is no fixed cap on the upside, because there is no fixed cap on the stock price.
Example 2: buying a put
Section titled “Example 2: buying a put”Strike $45, premium $1.50 per share, so $150 for one contract. Breakeven is the strike minus the premium: $45 − $1.50 = $43.50.
| Stock at expiration | Put value per share | Profit per share | Profit per contract |
|---|---|---|---|
| $0 | $45 | $43.50 | $4,350 |
| $30 | $15 | $13.50 | $1,350 |
| $40 | $5 | $3.50 | $350 |
| $43.50 | $1.50 | $0 | $0 |
| $45 | $0 | −$1.50 | −$150 |
| $50 | $0 | −$1.50 | −$150 |
The put buyer gains when the stock falls below $43.50. The most a put can pay is when the stock goes to zero: ($45 − $0 − $1.50) × 100 = $4,350. That is large but limited, because a price cannot fall below zero. Again, the buyer’s worst case is losing the entire $150, which happens at any price of $45 or above.
Example 3: selling a call (unlimited loss)
Section titled “Example 3: selling a call (unlimited loss)”Now take Priya’s side of Example 1. She sells the $55 call and receives $200. Her result is the mirror image of Sam’s.
| Stock at expiration | Seller profit per contract |
|---|---|
| $50 | +$200 |
| $57 | $0 |
| $70 | −$1,300 |
| $100 | −$4,300 |
| $150 | −$9,300 |
If she does not own the shares (an uncovered or “naked” call), she must buy them at whatever the market price is in order to deliver them at $55. At $150 she loses $9,300, which is 46.5 times the $200 she collected. There is no price at which this stops. FINRA states that for the writer of an uncovered call the maximum loss is “theoretically unlimited” (FINRA, options). Stocks can jump overnight on news such as a takeover offer, so the loss can arrive before there is any chance to react, and the margin a broker requires can rise suddenly as the price moves against the seller.
Example 4: selling a put
Section titled “Example 4: selling a put”Take the other side of Example 2. The seller of the $45 put receives $150 and must buy 100 shares at $45 if assigned, which takes 45 × 100 = $4,500.
- Stock at $50 at expiration: the put expires unused and the seller keeps $150.
- Stock at $40: the seller pays $45 for shares worth $40. Result: ($1.50 − $5) × 100 = −$350.
- Stock at $30: ($1.50 − $15) × 100 = −$1,350.
- Stock at $0: −$4,350, the mirror of the put buyer’s best case, and 29 times the premium received.
The loss is limited only by the stock’s fall to zero. “Limited” here still means losing almost the whole $4,500.
The four positions side by side
Section titled “The four positions side by side”| Position (one contract) | Paid or received | Breakeven | Maximum gain | Maximum loss |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Long $55 call | Pays $200 | $57 | No fixed limit | $200 |
| Long $45 put | Pays $150 | $43.50 | $4,350 | $150 |
| Short $55 call (uncovered) | Receives $200 | $57 | $200 | No fixed limit |
| Short $45 put | Receives $150 | $43.50 | $150 | $4,350 |
“Long” means you bought the contract; “short” means you sold it. Before costs, one side’s gain is exactly the other’s loss: options move risk between people for a price.
American and European exercise
Section titled “American and European exercise”The two common exercise styles differ in timing. FINRA explains that an American-style contract “may be exercised at any time between the date of purchase and the expiration date”, while a European-style contract “may only be exercised during a period of time on its expiration date”. Options on individual US stocks are generally American-style; many index options are European-style. Check the contract specifications rather than assuming.
For a seller of an American-style option, this means assignment can come early, on any day before expiration, not only at the end. A put seller can be asked to buy the shares weeks ahead of the date they had in mind.
What assignment looks like
Section titled “What assignment looks like”When a holder exercises, the clearing system assigns the obligation to a seller, and that seller’s broker then picks an account. The seller usually learns about it from a notice after the fact. A call seller who is assigned must deliver 100 shares per contract at the strike; a put seller must pay the strike for 100 shares per contract. If the account does not hold the shares or the cash, the broker may use margin or close positions, possibly at unfavourable prices. Many brokers also exercise options that finish in the money at expiration automatically unless told otherwise, so a buyer who forgets can end up with 100 shares per contract and the cash bill to match.
Try it by hand
Section titled “Try it by hand”Pick a strike and premium of your own and draw the payoff table before looking at anything else:
- List prices well below the strike, at the strike, at the breakeven, and well above it.
- For each, apply the one rule, subtract (or, for a seller, add) the premium, and multiply by 100.
Notice how the buyer’s losses stop at the premium while the seller’s keep growing.
Then check your table in the option payoff calculator: enter the same leg and compare its breakeven, maximum loss and payoff rows with yours.
Common mistakes
Section titled “Common mistakes”- Forgetting the multiplier. A “$2 option” costs $200 per contract. Ten contracts at $2 is $2,000, controlling 1,000 shares.
- Thinking a rising stock means a profitable call. In Example 1 the stock rose from $50 to $55 and the buyer still lost 100%. The stock must clear the breakeven before expiration.
- Treating premium received as safe income. The seller’s gain is capped at the premium, and the possible loss is many times larger, without limit for an uncovered call.
- Assuming you can only be assigned at expiration. American-style options can be assigned on any business day.
- Ignoring costs and spreads. Real fills, commissions and bid-ask spreads move every breakeven against you.
Real-world context
Section titled “Real-world context”Before a US broker-dealer approves an account for options, FINRA Rule 2360 requires it to deliver the current options disclosure document and to gather essential facts about the customer, including investment objectives and investment experience and knowledge (accessed 2026-11-19). Brokers commonly use those answers to decide which kinds of option trades an account may make, and uncovered call writing is usually among the most restricted. On an option chain, each expiration lists strikes with call quotes on one side and put quotes on the other, in per-share prices.
Quick check
Section titled “Quick check”- A call has a $30 strike and costs $1.20. What is the breakeven at expiration, and what is one contract’s profit if the stock finishes at $34?
Answer to question 1
Breakeven is $30 + $1.20 = $31.20. At $34 the call is worth $4, so the profit is ($34 − $30 − $1.20) × 100 = $280, before costs.
- You buy three put contracts at $0.80. What is the most you can lose?
Answer to question 2
3 × $0.80 × 100 = $240, the total premium paid. A buyer cannot lose more than the premium.
- Why is the loss on an uncovered call described as unlimited, while the loss on a sold put is not?
Answer to question 3
The call seller must deliver shares at the strike however high the price goes, and there is no upper limit on a stock price. The put seller must buy at the strike, and the most the shares can lose is their whole value, because a price cannot go below zero. That is still a very large loss.
- You sold an American-style put that expires in a month. Can you be assigned next week?
Answer to question 4
Yes. American-style options can be exercised by the holder on any business day before expiration, and the seller can be assigned at that point.
Key takeaways
Section titled “Key takeaways”- A call is the right to buy, a put the right to sell, at the strike until expiration; the seller takes the matching obligation for the premium.
- Standard contracts cover 100 shares, so multiply every quoted price by 100.
- Buyers can lose 100% of the premium, and often do when the stock does not move far enough, soon enough.
- Sellers keep at most the premium and can lose far more: without limit on an uncovered call, and down to the stock’s whole value on a put.
- American-style options can be exercised and assigned before expiration.
Next steps
Section titled “Next steps”Read Intrinsic and extrinsic value to see what an option is worth before expiration. For the order mechanics that apply to options too, see Order types, and for limiting how much one position can cost you, Position sizing, stops and R-multiples.
For educational purposes only. This material does not provide investment advice.